A post you created is gaining attention. The likes are climbing. Comments are coming in. People are sharing it. By every visible measure, it appears to be working.
But is it connecting with your most important audience?
Views, likes, shares, follows, and comments all tell us something useful. They show whether people noticed a message, interacted with it, or helped it travel farther. For organizations and advocates trying to understand what is working, those numbers matter.
But they usually do not answer one important question.
A message may receive enthusiastic support from people who already agree with us while giving us little evidence that it is creating understanding beyond that circle. It may spread widely without changing anyone’s understanding. It may generate dozens of comments while never connecting with the people whose understanding, support, or action could make a meaningful difference.
The missing metric is not another number on a dashboard. It is a more strategic question: Did this message connect with the audience whose response mattered most?
The Audience Depends on the Purpose
Who matters most will change from one message to another.
It might be someone we want to encourage to try a plant-based meal for the first time. It might be a person considering whether veganism fits their values. It could be a potential donor deciding whether to support an animal sanctuary, a local official considering a proposed industrial pig farm, or a restaurant owner deciding whether to add more plant-based options.
The purpose of the message determines whose response matters most.
Imagine two advocacy posts receiving the same number of likes. One celebrates a local vegan community’s recent outreach event and thanks volunteers for showing up, sharing photos, and supporting one another. Its purpose is to encourage current vegans and strengthen a sense of community. Most of its engagement comes from within that community. In that case, the message may be doing exactly what it was created to do.
The second post explains what happens to calves in the dairy industry and is intended to help dairy consumers reconsider their choices. It may be widely shared, but if most of that sharing occurs among people who already avoid dairy, the numbers alone cannot tell us whether the message connected with the people it most needed to influence.
The same numbers can signal success for one message and a missed opportunity for another, depending on what each is trying to accomplish.
Why Effective Communication Matters for Advocacy
The larger issue is not the performance of any single post, but the role effective communication plays in moving advocacy forward.
Ending animal exploitation will require changes in culture, consumer behavior, institutional practices, public policy, political priorities, and the number of people willing to participate actively in advocacy. Communication is not the only force needed to produce those changes. It cannot by itself improve plant-based products, lower prices, revise institutional menus, or pass new laws.
But those changes cannot gain widespread support, participation, or legitimacy without effective communication.
Communication helps people understand unfamiliar ideas. It builds public support, recruits advocates, strengthens campaigns, influences decision-makers, encourages donations, creates demand, and helps new possibilities become socially accepted. It enables other forms of movement work to spread and gain influence.
In that sense, communication is not the entire solution. It is a multiplier and an enabling force for nearly every other solution.
Caring deeply about animals is essential. But caring deeply is not the same as communicating effectively. A message that feels powerful, truthful, or morally clear to the person creating it may still produce defensiveness, disengagement, or misunderstanding in the people it was intended to move.
Effective communication asks us to consider more than the facts we want to present. It requires attention to audience resistance, framing, identity, tone, emotional flow, narrative structure, message purpose, and the action or response we hope to encourage.
Audience awareness is central to all of these elements.
What Research Suggests About Knowing the Audience
Research on AI-assisted persuasion offers a useful illustration. In a controlled experiment involving short debates, researchers compared people debating other people with people debating GPT-4. When GPT-4 had access to basic information about the person it was addressing, it was significantly more persuasive than human opponents. Without that audience information, its measured advantage was smaller and not statistically significant.[1]
The practical lesson is not simply that AI can be persuasive. It is that communication becomes more effective when it is shaped around the people receiving it, including their perspectives, concerns, values, and circumstances.
When advocates are most effective, they apply this understanding deliberately. They do not communicate with legislators, journalists, donors, volunteers, organizational partners, and members of the public in exactly the same way. They recognize that the same argument, tone, example, or story will not connect equally well with every audience.
The challenge is to make that discipline a consistent part of everything we create, including the fast-moving posts, emails, scripts, presentations, and campaign materials that fill our daily work.
Before publishing a message, we can pause and ask:
- What do we want this communication to accomplish?
- Whose response matters most to that purpose?
- What might help that audience become more open, interested, or willing to act?
Asking those questions does not mean abandoning moral clarity or weakening the case for animals. It means communicating that case in a way that people are more able and willing to receive.
How Vegan Rise One Can Help
Vegan Rise One is being developed to help advocates turn effective communication principles into consistent practice. VR1 Academy helps advocates understand messaging principles involving audience awareness, personal identity, emotional engagement, persuasion theory, narrative structure and more.
VR1 AI is designed to help advocates apply those principles to real communication. It can support users in identifying the intended audience, anticipating likely resistance, evaluating whether a message fits its purpose, and exploring ways to make the content more likely to connect.
The persuasion study suggests why this kind of AI-supported audience awareness may be valuable. AI is not a replacement for an advocate’s knowledge, judgment, experience, or understanding of the situation. Its value comes from helping the advocate examine the message more deliberately from the perspective of the people it needs to influence.
That matters because ending animal exploitation will require more than people who care deeply. It will require growing numbers of people who participate actively and communicate effectively across many audiences, situations, and pathways to change.
Likes, shares, and follows can tell us that something happened.
The deeper question is whether the right people noticed, understood, cared, or took the next step.
Are we connecting with our most important audience?
Reference
[1] Salvi, Francesco, Manoel Horta Ribeiro, Riccardo Gallotti, and Robert West. “On the Conversational Persuasiveness of GPT-4.” Nature Human Behaviour, 2025, 9, 1645–1653.
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-025-02194-6
And now, a brief update on what’s new with Vegan Rise One.
Something New:
VR1 AI Demo and Beta Access Request
The updated VR1 AI demo is live on the Vegan Rise One website. It shows the first round of Beta 2 improvements, especially the new Evaluate and Rewrite workflow. In Beta 1, VR1 AI could evaluate a message and provide a scorecard and report. In Beta 2, it can now use that evaluation to create a recommended rewrite, helping improve content you bring into VR1 as well as content originally created through VR1 AI.
Beta 2 access requests are now open through the new request form. You can find request buttons on the Vegan Rise One website.
Receive future issues of the Connection newsletter. Original articles, practical insights, and Vegan Rise One updates delivered to your inbox.
Share This Article
Copy the link to share it anywhere, or use one of the options below.